The West Suburban Conference has proposed splitting public and private schools into separate IHSA playoff brackets.
The conference, whose members include Glenbard West, submitted two proposals that would change how boundaried and non-boundaried schools compete for state titles. The proposals would affect football and seven other bracketed sports, Shaw Local reported Nov. 6.
Non-boundaried schools, including private schools and others without geographic attendance boundaries, can draw students from wider areas. The debate over whether that creates an unfair postseason advantage has persisted for decades in Illinois High School Association (IHSA) circles.
How the proposals differ
Proposal 8 is the more aggressive option. It would create entirely separate postseason brackets for boundaried and non-boundaried schools. In football, eight classifications would remain: six for public schools and two for private and non-boundaried programs. According to Stateline Sports Network, 75 percent of playoff berths would go to boundaried schools and 25 percent to non-boundaried schools, with qualifiers selected separately.
There are 89 non-boundaried 11-man football programs in the state, according to Shaw Local's Steve Soucie. The IHSA Board would set enrollment cutoffs annually to divide the two non-boundaried classifications. That language is not written into the proposal itself.
Proposal 15 takes a softer approach. Public and private schools would stay in the same classifications but follow separate paths to the semifinals. Three of four semifinal spots would be reserved for boundaried schools. One spot would go to a non-boundaried school. The two sides could still meet in title games.
Both proposals were submitted by the West Suburban Conference, whose 14 members include Glenbard West, Downers Grove North, Downers Grove South, Hinsdale Central, York and Oak Park-River Forest.
Why it matters locally
Over the past five seasons, private and non-boundaried schools have earned 46 football semifinal bids, Shaw Local reported. In 2025, those schools claimed nine semifinal spots and won five state championships. Proposal 15 would cap non-boundaried semifinal bids at eight per year, one per classification.
The proposals would also reach beyond football. Girls volleyball, boys and girls basketball, boys and girls soccer, baseball, and softball all use bracketed postseason formats that would be affected.
Separately, Glenbard East's Tony Millard of Lombard is one of four co-submitters on a bloc of proposals to reduce regular-season contest maximums across several sports, according to Stateline Sports Network. Those proposals cite concerns that Illinois plays more games than neighboring states, leaving students less practice time and rest.
What comes next
The 25 proposals in the IHSA's 2026-27 legislative cycle are being discussed at town meetings through Nov. 18, according to Shaw Local. The IHSA's legislative commission will then decide which proposals advance to a statewide membership ballot.
Shaw Local reported the vote would take place between Nov. 30 and Dec. 14. Stateline Sports Network, citing IHSA Associate Executive Director Matt Troha, reported the vote window as Dec. 1-15 with results announced Dec. 16.
The two West Suburban Conference proposals contradict each other and cannot both be implemented, Shaw Local reported. The conference has indicated it may withdraw one if the other is deemed more feasible. The IHSA could also bypass a membership vote on Proposal 15 by enacting a variant as board policy.
Any proposal that passes a majority vote would take effect for the 2027-28 school year.







